Stories
Cathedral Basilica of St. Augustine, Saint AugustinePhoto: Carlstak, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Church · Saint Augustine

What happened to St. Augustine's cathedral in 1887?

38 Cathedral Place, Saint Augustine, Florida

A fire swept through St. Augustine's cathedral on April 12, 1887, but its coquina exterior walls survived. Henry Flagler contributed money toward rebuilding, and architect James Renwick Jr. rebuilt and enlarged the church, adding a concrete bell tower. One bell, salvaged from an earlier church, bears the year 1682.

  • 2 stories
  • On 2 tours

The story of Cathedral Basilica of St. Augustine

The whole storyStop 3 of St. Augustine Walking Tour: Nights of Lights and the Old City

The Church That Kept Burning Down

You're standing on Cathedral Place, at the northern edge of the plaza, facing the front of the Cathedral Basilica of St. Augustine. Start with the gables, the curving tops of the facade, where a bell hangs out in the open air, the way bells do in old Spanish mission churches. One of the bells here was salvaged from an earlier church, and it carries the date 1682. Hold that number in your head.

This congregation dates to 1565, when Spain founded St. Augustine. That makes it the oldest Christian congregation in the contiguous United States. Keeping a church standing here turned out to be much harder than starting one.

The first church of St. Augustine was simple and rapidly built, and it burned to the ground in 1586, when the English privateer Sir Francis Drake attacked the town. The replacement was straw and palmetto. It rotted in the humid air, then burned in 1599. In 1605, a third church went up, this time of timber, built by experienced builders. It lasted 95 years, though in disrepair, before it burned in 1702 during a failed English attack led by James Moore, the governor of Carolina.

After that, the church simply vanished for more than ninety years. An attempt to rebuild in 1707 failed, because the royal rebuilding money was misspent on provisions, soldiers' pay, and graft by public officials. Priests said Mass in the town hospital, which grew too small for the congregation and embarrassed it in front of Native American converts. Then the British held Florida from 1763 to 1784, and reconstruction was forgotten.

When Spain regained the colony, a new sense of civic pride led to the church in front of you, built between 1793 and 1797. Look at the front. You'll see curving Spanish bell gables, plain walls and a prominent niche for a statue. Around the door, the builders added something more formal: paired columns and a broken pediment, in a Neoclassical style.

And yes, it burned too. On April 12, 1887, fire swept through the old structure. This time the exterior walls could be saved. They're coquina, a soft stone formed from seashells that hardens when exposed to air. Henry Flagler contributed to the rebuilding, along with funds raised in a national appeal. A New York architect, James Renwick Jr., rebuilt and enlarged the church and added the bell tower. The new walls, tower included, are modern cast-in-place concrete.

So return to that bell. It's inscribed "Sancte Joseph. Ora Pro Nobis," a prayer to Saint Joseph, and the year 1682. It was salvaged from a previous church. Whatever the fires took, a bell from 1682 outlasted them, and it still hangs above a church that has been rebuilt again and again.

When you're ready, walk east about 250 meters, roughly four minutes, to the plaza and the Foot Soldiers Monument, where ordinary townspeople stood up to segregation in 1964.

Hear it where it happened. It plays at stop 3 of St. Augustine Walking Tour: Nights of Lights and the Old City (3 min), narrated as you walk. Unlock the tour for the audio, or try stop 1 free first.

Tours that stop here

Ghost walk
Saint Augustine, Florida

Haunted St. Augustine Walking Tour

Walk from the old fort to the Bridge of Lions through a city where centuries of history linger in stone and soil.

1 h 3 min · 8 stops · 1.6 mi · $4.99

Stop 4 of 8 on Haunted St. Augustine Walking Tour, between Tolomato Cemetery and Flagler College.

Stop 3 of 9 on St. Augustine Walking Tour, between The Oldest Wooden School House and The Plaza and the Foot Soldiers Monument.

Here for the season? Nights of Lights St. Augustine 2026: dates, parking and a walk.

Near Cathedral Basilica of St. Augustine

450 ft away

Casa Monica Hotel

The Casa Monica became the Alcazar Annex after a bridge linked it to another hotel.

650 ft away

Lightner Museum

A cafe now occupies the hotel's drained indoor swimming pool.

950 ft away

Villa Zorayda

St. Augustine's first poured concrete building was named after a literary princess.

0.3 mi away

Bridge of Lions

The doctor who donated the marble lions died before they were installed.

Sources